If Observer A was accelerating relative to Observer B, would they agree that it is Observer A that gained mass?

Well...If you watched what happened from instant to instant, in each instant the observers are separating at constant velocity and at this instant A and B would see each other's masses change according to special relativity. The only thing that breaks this symmetry is that we see that Observer A is the one that has used their rockets, and we have decided that Observer B will define the unaccelerated reference frame. If B were on the Earth and A were in a rocket, it is clear that any mass change would be ascribed to the motion of A, however, B looking at A would still see A moving away at increasing speeds relative to A's rest frame, which is a perfectly 'proper' frame for them to be using. Even if B were on the Earth, A would still see B and the Earth gain mass, even though A would never try to assert that they are in fact stationary and it is B and the Earth which are mysteriously accelerating away from A.

Relativity isn't slavishly symmetric when you establish who is actually doing the accelerating.


Copyright 1997 Dr. Sten Odenwald
Return to Ask the Astronomer.